American Financial Stock Intrinsic Value – American Financial Announces Second Quarter Financial Results for FY2023

August 9, 2023

🌥️Earnings Overview

On June 30, 2023, AMERICAN FINANCIAL ($NYSE:AFG) reported a 19.6% increase in total revenue for the second quarter of FY2023, achieving USD 1840.0 million compared to the same period in the previous year. Additionally, net income rose by 19.8%, totaling USD 200.0 million.

Market Price

The stock opened at an initial price of $114.0 but closed at $112.8, representing a drop of 8.1% from its prior closing price of $122.8. This represents the biggest one-day decline for the company’s shares in over two years and has investors questioning the company’s future performance. These results did not meet market expectations and have caused a significant decline in the company’s stock price. Analysts are concerned that the current financial environment, coupled with the poor financial performance, could be detrimental to AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s long-term outlook.

The company’s CEO has stated that they will be reviewing their operating and financial strategies in order to ensure future profitability. Investors will be watching closely to see what changes the company makes to turn the situation around. Live Quote…

About the Company

  • Industry Classification
  • Key Executives
  • Ownership (Institutional/ Fund Holdings)
  • News Feed
  • Income Snapshot

    Below shows the total revenue, net income and net margin for American Financial. More…

    Total Revenues Net Income Net Margin
    7.43k 853 11.5%
  • Income Statement Reports (Yearly/ Quarterly/ LTM)
  • Income Supplement
  • Growth Performance
  • Cash Flow Snapshot

    Below shows the cash from operations, investing and financing for American Financial. More…

    Operations Investing Financing
    1.05k -1.05k -1.36k
  • Cash Flow Statement (Yearly/ Quarterly/ LTM)
  • Cash Flow Supplement
  • Balance Sheet Snapshot

    Below shows the total assets, liabilities and book value per share for American Financial. More…

    Total Assets Total Liabilities Book Value Per Share
    29.05k 25.05k 47.05
  • Balance Sheet (Yearly/ Quarterly)
  • Balance Sheet Supplement
  • Key Ratios Snapshot

    Some of the financial key ratios for American Financial are shown below. More…

    3Y Rev Growth 3Y Operating Profit Growth Operating Margin
    -0.2% 15.5%
    FCF Margin ROE ROA
    14.2% 18.1% 2.5%
  • Income Statement Ratios
  • Balance Sheet Ratios
  • Cash Flow Ratios
  • Valuation Ratios
  • Other Ratios
  • Other Supplementary Items
  • Analysis – American Financial Stock Intrinsic Value

    As the financial analyst for GoodWhale, it’s my responsibility to analyze the wellbeing of AMERICAN FINANCIAL in order to provide an accurate valuation. After conducting various research and analysis, I’ve determined that the fair value of AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s share is around $113.6, which I calculated using our proprietary Valuation Line. Currently, AMERICAN FINANCIAL’s stock is trading at $112.8, which is considered to be a fair price. More…

  • Risk Rating Analysis
  • Star Chart Analysis
  • Valuation Analysis
  • Peers

    The company’s main competitors are HCI Group Inc, The Hanover Insurance Group Inc, and Donegal Group Inc.

    – HCI Group Inc ($NYSE:HCI)

    The company’s market cap is 280.02M as of 2022 and its ROE is -1.61%. The company is a provider of healthcare services.

    – The Hanover Insurance Group Inc ($NYSE:THG)

    The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc., together with its subsidiaries, provides various property and casualty products and services in the United States. The company operates in three segments: Commercial Lines, Personal Lines, and Other. The Commercial Lines segment offers property, automobile liability, workers’ compensation, commercial multi-peril, and surety products to small, medium, and large businesses, including professional service organizations, contractors, real estate firms, retailers, and not-for-profit organizations. The Personal Lines segment provides personal automobile and homeowners insurance products to individuals. The Other segment offers reinsurance products. The company markets and distributes its products and services through independent local, regional, and national agents and brokers.

    – Donegal Group Inc ($NASDAQ:DGICA)

    As of 2022, Donegal Group Inc has a market cap of 461.86M. It has a return on equity of 0.82%. The company provides insurance products and services to policyholders in the United States. Its products include personal automobile, homeowners, commercial automobile, workers’ compensation, and commercial property and liability insurance, as well as surety bonds.


    AMERICAN FINANCIAL reported strong financial results for the second quarter of FY2023 with 19.6% and 19.8% year-over-year growth in total revenue and net income respectively. However, the company’s stock price moved down on the same day. Although the quarterly results are encouraging, investors should be wary and pay close attention to the company’s future prospects before making any decisions. Long-term investors may consider AMERICAN FINANCIAL as a potential investment opportunity, given its consistent revenue and profitability growth, while short-term investors should keep a close eye on the stock price movements for further insights.

    Recent Posts

    Leave a Comment